Thursday, February 27, 2025
Wednesday, February 26, 2025
RBI’s $10 billion swap: What does it hope to achieve: Indian Express 25th February 2025
The RBI has already started on the path of cutting the repo rate. The assumption is that inflation is very much under control. The repo rate has been cut once in February and it is expected that there could be two more cuts this year. But the problem is of liquidity — the banking system has been in a deficit for a protracted period of time. This situation is likely to persist till the end of March. The challenge really is that interest rate cuts may not lead to easy transmission unless liquidity is normalised. Therefore, simultaneously, the RBI has been focusing on enhancing liquidity in the system.
The framework introduced since 2020 looks at three major instruments for inducing liquidity into the system. These are open market operations, variable rate repo auctions (for different tenures) and forex buy-sell swaps. The first two are well known measures which have been used in the past too. Open market operations involve buying government securities from banks. The VRR auctions give money to banks for fixed tenures on the back of government securities as collateral. The swap is the new concept being used when conditions are quite uncertain in the forex market.
The RBI will be holding a buy-sell swap for $10 billion on February 28 for which dollars would have to be handed over to the RBI on March 6 by successful bidders. The swap is for a period of three years which means that the redemption takes place on March 6, 2028. In simple language, on February 28 there will be an auction for $10 billion where the RBI will buy dollars from banks at a premium to be decided by the market. Under the terms of this bid, banks can sell to the RBI at the prevailing price on the 28th and receive the rupee equivalent on March 6. On March 6, 2028, the banks will have to buy back the dollars from the RBI by paying in rupees along with the premium.
The RBI had conducted one such swap on a similar basis on January 28 for $5 billion. The RBI reference rate was Rs 86.64/$ and the premium was 97 paise. The transaction would be reversed after six months on August 4. Intuitively, if the rupee remains stable during this period, banks will be better off as the cost would work out to just 1.1 per cent.
In the past, the RBI has used swaps mainly for inducing dollars into the system which involved selling dollars and then buying them back after the agreed period. The reverse is now being undertaken as the target is to infuse liquidity against the objective of providing dollars. With these two auctions of $15 billion, the RBI would have induced Rs 1.30 lakh crore into the system. This is quite substantial. This is a third window being used by the RBI which will work out to be cheaper for banks. It is not surprising that in the earlier auction for $5 billion, the bids received were around $26 billion.
The significant part of the $10 billion auction is that the buy-back by banks would take place after three years. Thus, while it has stretched the repayment period, it will again be carried out in March. March is a different kind of month in terms of liquidity as it typically tends to get sticky especially as the advance tax payments are due on March 15 and there is the usual rush to push credit by banks to meet their targets. Besides these two factors, GST payments too would tend to increase. Therefore, paying the RBI the rupee equivalent of $10 billion along with the premium after three years in March would be something to consider for banks.
It can be assumed that the RBI will continue to use all these three windows besides the overnight repo auctions (which were resurrected recently) to provide liquidity. The forex swap would fall between a permanent infusion which is what open market operations do and VRRs which are short term in nature. This is a fine blend.
Wednesday, February 19, 2025
There is no alternative to the dollar as the world's anchor currency : MInt 20th February 2025
https://www.livemint.com/opinion/online-views/dedollarization-dollar-assets-forex-reserves-global-trade-currency-renminbi-yuan-yen-pound-euro-imf-donald-trump-trade-11739879691245.html
Monday, February 17, 2025
Is It Time To Have A Luxury Tax In Place? Free Press Journal: 15th February 2025
One of the most popular Indian cricketers is said to own 70 bikes and at least a dozen luxury cars. Data from the Federation of Automobiles Dealers Association indicates that around 35,000 luxury cars, costing at least Rs 50 lakhs each, were sold in FY24, including BMWs, Mercedes, and Audis.
One of the most popular Indian cricketers is said to own 70 bikes and at least a dozen luxury cars. Data from the Federation of Automobiles Dealers Association indicates that around 35,000 luxury cars, costing at least Rs 50 lakhs each, were sold in FY24, including BMWs, Mercedes, and Audis. There were around a little less than 1000 Porsches sold in the same year. At an even higher price level, there were over 100 Lamborghinis sold, while the count for Rolls Royce was about 60. Now a Porsche can start at around Rs 1 crore, while a Lamborghini is close to Rs 3 crore. A Rolls Royce can cost upwards of Rs 7 crore.
There was also news of some industrialists buying a series of apartments in Mumbai’s prime locality at over Rs 200 crore. It is not certain if the numbers are true, but there have been similar numbers spoken of celebrities buying homes, which can go up to Rs 100 crore each. Cricketers in categories A and C have done well for the country and purchased multiple homes, which could be costing upwards of Rs 30 crore each in places like Mumbai or Delhi.
For each of these purchases, there is an official trail of the income earned or loan taken with a history of tax returns. Therefore, there can be no issue in terms of capacity to pay for such indulgences. In fact, from a capitalist standpoint, it can be argued that these are the fruits of hard work and business, where money is earned and invested in these luxuries. All such purchases add to the GDP of the country and, hence, are useful. In a way, when the general masses are unable to spend money due to inflation and consumption is down, the premium products have done well due to this class.
Now, the idea for the government should be whether or not to impose a luxury tax on such purchases. There have been talks of a wealth tax being imposed, which has arguments on both sides. Anyone who has accumulated wealth has paid all the taxes that are due, which can be a stamp duty on property or GST on vehicles or capital gains tax on equity gains. Therefore, taxing the same for retaining wealth would not be fair. However, there is scope to revisit the tax rates at the time of purchase.
example, the stamp duty in Maharashtra is fixed at 6%, which does not take into account whether the house costs Rs 1 crore or Rs 100 crore. Here it is assumed that as it is an ad valorem tax, which is on value, it is equitable as higher value homes pay higher duties. But logically, if a person is buying a home for Rs 100 crore, imposing a luxury tax or cess of 20% would be very much in order. The state government can earn substantial revenue as it falls in its jurisdiction.
In the case of automobiles, the GST is 28% at the higher end with a composition cess of 22%, which adds to 50%. But this has not been a deterrent to such purchases, as they are often style or position statements. Based on the sales of cars mentioned above in the starting range of Rs 50 lakhs, the total cost would be around Rs 17,500 crore at the lower end (as often those who can afford such vehicles would purchase higher variants, which can go up to double the price). An additional 10% luxury tax or cess can add Rs 1750 crore as revenue at the lowest end. In fact, in the past, when such luxury cars were imported, the tariff was 100%, which did not really push demand down, given that they were status symbols. Against this background, anything less than 100% is still something that sounds reasonable and will not act as a deterrent. Hence, if the money spent on 60 Rolls Royces amounted to, at least, Rs 420 crore in FY24, imposing another 50% luxury GST over the existing 50% could have garnered another Rs 210 crore.
There is reason for the government to revisit the tax structures for luxury goods, where lines can be drawn on what constitutes the same. A house over Rs 20 crore could get classified as one in a metro city, while a vehicle above Rs 50 lakhs would fall in this category. The same can be extended to even hotel stays, where there is accommodation in the higher price bands. At present, it is capped at 28%. But a room rate of say Rs 50,000 and above can be levied to garner more revenue.
Today, there is skewness when it comes to the distribution of income. While it is true that even those at the bottom levels are witnessing improvements in their standards of living, the growth in wealth at the higher level has been more pronounced. Weddings could involve a large expenditure outlay, which can be taxed, as this could be in various forms such as clothing, jewellery, food and beverages, resorts, decorations, travel, and so on. There is value added as all expenses add to consumer spending, which is based on income earned on which all taxes have been paid. There is, hence, a justification in taxing what can be called ostentatious consumption through a luxury tax or cess. This would help in garnering revenue for the government. In turn, such revenue can be used as part of the resources that are deployed for direct cash transfers to the poor through monthly payouts to women or any other vulnerable section of society.
Intuitively, it can be seen that a lot of the money that is spent on these luxuries is through the sale of securities acquired through stock options or ownership of the same or by leveraging brand value, which holds for sportspeople or film stars. Hence, these incomes may not strictly come from the core profession as salary for those in the corporate world or games for sportspersons. This tax could also serve at the limit to encourage the elites to save money once demand is satiated. Hence, it would be helpful any which way, as such demand is agnostic to price levels.
One earth, one family: Book Review Financial Express: 16th February 2025
Being in charge of hosting G20 deliberations may sound like routine business for any nation given that this privilege is rotated among member countries. But the conditions under which India had to organise this summit were challenging. Coming close on the back of the pandemic and right in the middle of the Ukraine war, getting countries together to discuss a plethora of issues ranging from global cooperation to climate change was nothing short of an achievement.
This story has been narrated by the Sherpa for this purpose, Amitabh Kant, in this rather comprehensive book on how India successfully managed these challenges by getting everybody on the discussion table. This is why the suffix ‘Mount’ sounds quite appropriate. Kant, who headed the famous NITI Aayog, is known for his prowess in taking on such assignments in the course of his career, being also associated with transforming tourism in Kerala.
The author thanks Prime Minister Narendra Modi for enabling the successful completion of the G20, writing that the PM’s functioning can be a good template for a CEO of an organisation. There are five qualities that need to be mentioned here. The first is taking a long-term perspective of any issue, which means not thinking of today but tomorrow. This quality combines well with empathy for people, which is a potent potion for success.
The second is the art of listening, where leaders need to spend time listening to people. This helps in assimilating multiple views, as a final decision can be taken after weighing all considerations. It reflects humility, because being willing to listen to others requires a different kind of mindset.
The third is remaining calm even under pressure. Losing one’s temper when under pressure can cause hasty decisions to be taken, which is eschewed when one is able to deal with all provocations with equanimity. This is natural in the course of any meeting, especially when there are differing views from countries with varying governance structures. Fourth was the optimistic approach taken, which helped mould mindsets in a positive frame all the time. And last is the emphasis given to physical and mental well-being. These are the lessons in management that the author highlights after successfully completing the assignment as Sherpa for the G20.
The slogan for the G20 meet was ‘one earth, one family, one future’, which is just about what is required to keep global integration alive, such that all can benefit from this collaborative effort. Reiterating this theme throughout the long period of deliberations helped to bring all countries together and there was acceptance that they needed to work together.
The author believes that under the PM’s guidance India was able to position itself as a bridge to promote healing in a world divided by geopolitical differences. This is required to build a more sustainable future. Now strategically the G20 discussions were turned towards the priorities of the global south, which does credit to India. For example, the African Union was given a full membership to the G20, a momentous step in shaping global governance, especially as it covers the voices of 1.4 billion people (which is the size of India).
The author writes that the approach taken by the PM was responsible for building consensus on several issues. One of the examples here is the tryst with creating global climate action. As the world grappled with this subject, we were able to focus on sustainable development and hence strike a balance between economic growth and environmental conundrums. This was necessary because several global agreements put the responsibility on developing nations, which could involve asymmetric sacrifices.
Kant goes into fairly comprehensive details on how his team went around accomplishing the job, starting from the arrangements to steering discussions in the desired manner so as to optimise the time spent on these deliberations. There was clarity of thought, as there were 15 principles drawn up that were the cornerstones of these meetings. These included a wide array of subjects starting with Ukraine to being consistent with the UN charters to war on food and energy security to peace across the world.
One of the interesting issues covered related to a new look for multilateral institutions for the 21st century. Here he speaks of how the global financial infrastructure needed to be overhauled. In particular, the IMF and World Bank have to probably also incorporate climate change and crossborder issues in their mandates. This forum was also used by India to showcase the resounding success of India’s digital public infrastructure. Here, the success of the famous JAM trinity and use of technology for better delivery of direct benefit transfers was the high point.
So how does multilateralism stand after all these talks? This is surely work in progress as there are several changes in the global economic order over the years. The Ukraine war exposed the limited power of the United Nations Security Council, which was unable to broker any kind of peace. Similarly, the US-China economic conflict is just growing by the day, which has taken a serious tone with the new US President specifically targeting the country. WTO has lost steam with most member countries now having their own regional trade agreements.
In this context he also talks of the most recent COP-29 held in Baku where the issue of climate change was the focus. The global south seems to be bearing the brunt of climate impact even though its contribution to greenhouse gas emissions is the least. The crux, according to Kant, of multilateralism surviving is the existence of political will to stay connected.
This book is quite remarkable as it gives a deep understanding of the way in which the global economic order operates. It is also a help book on how to get different entities onto a common platform for successful deliberations. In the end one would say kudos to Kant for such flawless execution of the project.
Book details:
Title: How India Scaled Mt G20: The Inside Story of the G20 Presidency
Author: Amitabh Kant
Publisher: Rupa Publications
Number of pages: 256
Price: Rs 595
Thursday, February 13, 2025
Rs 1 lakh crore to boost consumption, says Bank of Baroda's Chief Economist Madan Sabnavis: Business Today Feb 16 2025
The Budget is a finely crafted document that starts with the fiscal deficit and manages all components in a cogent manner while embellishing the same with some forward-looking policies to deliver a very neat package. The background for the Budget was different, as the overall size of the exercise came in lower at Rs 47.16 lakh crore in FY25 as against a budgeted number of Rs 48.20 lakh core. Therefore, the increase of 7.4% in size over the Revised Estimates at Rs 50.65 lakh core for FY26 is the overall base that can be looked at closely.
Looking at all the numbers, the Budget has balanced various objectives. The income tax relief was very much on cards and the release of Rs 1 lakh crore is a booster for consumption and savings, depending on how the taxpayer uses this benefit. Interestingly, the income tax collections would be Rs1.81 lakh crore higher in FY26, against Rs 2.13 lakh crore last year. The lower amount would account for the relief offered to taxpayers. Intuitively, it can be said that if such a relief was not provided, the estimated collections would have been higher.
Second, the corporate tax collections have been taken to grow by 10.4% over 7.6% in FY24. The message is that corporate performance would be better this year. This should be encouraging for industry as corporate performance has been subdued in the first three quarters of FY25. The economy is to grow by almost the same rate of 6.3-6.8% (Economic Survey) in FY26, as compared with 6.4% in FY25 (Economic Survey). If the corporate sector does perform better, there could very well be an upside to the gross domestic product (GDP) growth forecast too for FY26.
Third, the excise collections on account of fuel have been kept unchanged. This would mean that citizens can be assured of unchanged prices in petrol and diesel. Therefore, if global prices were to rise, there would be protection provided by apportioning the cost between the government and the oil marketing companies. This is a positive from the point of view of inflation.
Fourth, there has been a plethora of changes in customs tariffs, with the proclivity to reduce, rather than increase. The customs collections have been assumed to rise by just 2%. Two conclusions can be drawn. First is that this review could have been made keeping in mind the talks that India will have with the US on tariffs being imposed here. Second, given the state of the global economy and the impact on trade, the assumption here is that imports per se may not be increasing sharply and that the currency would be largely stable.
Fifth, the non-tax revenue components also throw up some useful insights. The dividend/surplus from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), public sector banks, public financial institutions are to be at the same level as last year at Rs 2.56 lakh crore (Rs 2.34 lakh crore last year). This means that there could be similar dividend transferred by the RBI, which had crossed the Rs 2 lakh mark in FY25. It would be interesting to see which components would generate this surplus with the sale of foreign exchange being the foremost source of income.
Sixth, the net borrowing programme has been targeted at slightly lower than last year at Rs 11.54 lakh crore. Here the gross borrowings are higher at Rs 14.82 lakh crore against Rs 14 lakh crore last year. But to ensure the market is not pressurised, the Budget has drawn from the Goods and Services Tax (GST) compensation fund to address some of the redemptions, which has helped to stabilise this amount. This is positive news for the market and bond yields will remain stable. The budgetary impact will, hence, be neutral.
Seventh, for financing the fiscal deficit the Budget is not taking into account any short-term borrowings and show less importance to small savings. This implies there is intent to stick more to market borrowings rather than dip into the National Small Saving Fund. In a way, it is more prudent as the cost of market borrowings is lower than that from the small savings account.
Eight, on the expenditure side the Budget has continued to focus on all the social welfare schemes.
The largest increases have been witnessed for the PM-Awas Yojana, which includes both rural and urban schemes. This is interesting because the revised numbers for FY25 were much lower than the budgeted numbers. Quite clearly, this scheme has to be pushed harder to ensure that more affordable homes are constructed and bought by the relevant sections of society.
Other outlays like subsidies and the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme, PM-Kisan have been retained at the FY25 levels, which will maintain the momentum. These are important because they are supplements for fostering consumption as they release funds or add to income directly when they are cash transfers.
The Budget has, hence, been drawn up quite dexterously, starting with the fiscal deficit ratio playing the role of anchor around which the other numbers have been built to deliver the best returns. Based on a conservative nominal GDP growth of 10.1%, there could be an upside benefit if it turns out to be higher in FY26.
Monday, February 10, 2025
Sunday, February 9, 2025
Credit policy supplements Budget growth boost: Business line online 7th February 2025
A perspective shift in managing growth-inflation mix, as well as bank regulation stand out in new RBI Governor’s statement
The first difference lies in acknowledging the achievements of the flexible inflation targeting framework, introduced in 2016. The fact that inflation has largely been within the band has been a vindication of its effectiveness. Further, the statement does convey the message that unlike the past when there was a focus on inflation being close to the target of 4 per cent on durable basis, a flexible band could be the driving factor to balance growth-inflation dynamics. Therefore, a band of 4-6 per cent would be more important than the 4 per cent number.
The second point made upfront was on some of the new regulations that are in the offing. There was assurance given that the central bank would be consulting with stakeholders and the implementation would be gradual, to enable the system to absorb these changes. This will bring relief to banks. Interestingly, there was mention of a trade-off between efficiency and cost when regulation is imposed.
The cut in repo rate was almost a given and opens the door for more rate cuts during the year. It can be said that as far as borrowers and lenders are concerned the peak interest rate regime has ended. The decision at the micro bank level will depend on other considerations, including liquidity.
Inflation outlook
The forecast of inflation at 4.2 per cent for next year could have an upside. This is so because two sets of factors need to be considered. The first is that even a normal monsoon always has been associated with periods of sharp increases in vegetable prices, particularly in the September-December period. This problem will remain until such time that the composition of the CPI is changed with the weights for products like tomatoes, potatoes and onions reflecting their share in consumption basket.
The second is the pressure of imported inflation. As the central bank’s position on the rupee is that the currency will be driven by market forces with intervention only in the event of excess volatility, there is reason to believe that the rupee can be pressurised depending on global factors, which are fluid as of date. Therefore, the threat of imported inflation does exist. The question is whether the government will raise prices of fuel products if the imported cost of crude oil increases sharply.
Further, core inflation would tend to be higher than that in FY25 as companies have been increasing prices of their products due to both demand (for services) and cost pressures (manufactured goods). In fact, historically, post 2012, core inflation has averaged 5-6 per cent and the low numbers witnessed in FY25 have been due to fortuitous conditions.
Growth forecast
The growth forecast made by the RBI at 6.7 per cent for the year looks reasonable; there can be an upside here, too. The push given by the government through the Budget along with the base effect should in the normal course lead to higher consumption and investment. The impediments of election uncertainty and high inflation which affected private investment, government spending and consumption in FY25 would not be potent factors in FY26. This number looks more optimistic, however, than what was projected in the Economic Survey which has placed growth in the range of 6.3-6.8 per cent.
Based on its assessment of the banking sector, the RBI appears to be fairly satisfied with financial stability. While no specific measures on liquidity were announced, it can be assumed that the central banks would continue with a combination of measures of OMO, VRR and dollar swaps to ensure that liquidity will be normalised. But interestingly, the Governor did point out to an anomaly where some banks have been parking funds with the RBI rather than lending in the call market. This was above ₹1 lakh crore on February 6. There is a clear nudge to banks to change this practice. This would help improve liquidity in the system.
The credit policy can be seen as an effective supplement to the Budget, where the government had focused on growth as the primary objective.
Monday, February 3, 2025
Sunday, February 2, 2025
The targets of Trump's strikes need not chicken out: Mint 3rd February 2025
https://www.livemint.com/opinion/online-views/madan-sabnavis-trump-tariff-targets-threats-india-tariff-king-export-duties-import-duties-colombia-usd-dollar-value-ally-11738227966803.html
Saturday, February 1, 2025
Five things stand out in Budget 2025 as it works on fiscal consolidation: Business Standard 1st Feb 2025
There are five things stand out in the Budget 2025 proposals as it works on the entire process of fiscal consolidation. To begin with, the government has assumed a rather conservative gross domestic product (GDP) growth rate of 10.1 per cent for FY26, which is the basis for all tax conjectures. Given that the world economy is in a state of flux as is the domestic economy, it always makes sense to be cautious on the GDP forecast so that there is no case of overstating revenue.
Ease Of Paying Taxes Should Be Considered: Free Press Journal: 1st Feb 2025
https://www.freepressjournal.in/analysis/ease-of-paying-taxes-should-be-considered
A budget for the middle class that tries to do a balancing act: Indian Express 1st Feb 2025
The Union Budget is a statement of accounts of the government, which says where money comes from and how it is spent. It is also the most potent policy instrument the government has as these numbers are drafted keeping in mind the larger goals of the economy in the areas of consumption, investment, inflation and interest rates. This year, two concerns were paramount: The first was consumption and the other was the government’s capex. In FY 25, there was a modicum of sluggishness in both. The budget has attempted to address both these issues from the fiscal side.
The budget has attempted to not just revive but also accelerate the processes. The income tax slabs have been moderated, which would result in Rs 1 lakh crore revenue being foregone. Intuitively, the amount in the hands of the taxpayers would be used for consumption and savings. Assuming that 70 per cent is spent, there can be expectations of higher spending by the salaried class. Typically, this would be spent on consumer goods and services. As services have been witnessing a sharp increase in recent times, it can be expected to accelerate.
he other area is capex which has high multiplier effects on the economy. The focus areas are roads, railways and defence, which account for 63 per cent of the total capital expenditure — or 75 per cent, if transfers to states are excluded. The outlay for this year has almost been maintained at last year’s budgeted number of Rs 11.2 lakh crore. With a full year to operate, this time it may be expected that there will be no shortfall, which will help to speed up capex as well as bring in private investment. Industries like cement, steel and machinery are likely to benefit from these outlays.
The government’s capex has strong backward linkages in an indirect manner as it stimulates investment made by infrastructure industries which, in turn, employ more people. In other words, this process has a distinct connection with job creation. This will continue in FY26. The difference in approach to investment that has been spelt out in the budget is important — it focuses on the PPP model to push up capital formation. This is at the industry level — here all ministries would be involved — as well as in urban infrastructure.
The spending on social welfare deserves mention here. The government has been supporting the poor through schemes like PM-Kisan, NREGA, and PM Awas. These would continue to be focus areas. The free food scheme has received an outlay of Rs 2 lakh crore and the interests of the less privileged class have been addressed. The outlays provided in the budget will ensure that the safety net remains unaffected. This is important at a time when inflation is still a concern for all.
Of late, budgets have tended to keep in mind the market impact as borrowings have increased sharply after the Covid pandemic, putting pressure on the markets as funding is an issue. However, ever since the government decided to roll back the deficits, albeit gradually, the gross borrowing programme has largely been range-bound. This has meant that the squeeze on liquidity has been limited. By bringing down the fiscal deficit ratio to 4.4 per cent for FY26, the budget continues on this path. This is good for the banking sector in particular given that there are challenges in garnering deposits. The bond markets will start off on a positive note on Monday as the fiscal numbers do indicate stable bond yields.
The budget has assumed a conservative GDP growth — 10.1 per cent. This would ensure that growth is not overstated and with attendant spinoffs on revenue collection. In other words, the possibility of a higher revenue collection cannot be ruled out. This also means that expenditure can be incurred without cutting corners.
On the tax collections side, the buoyancy seen in income tax collections would continue this year. Revenues would rise by about 10 per cent, notwithstanding the concessions given in the budget. Corporate tax collection would increase by a similar amount which indicates that profits of companies would improve next year, which is good news.
On the whole, the Finance Minister has managed the budget quite dexterously given the limited space that was available since the objective of keeping to the agenda of lowering the fiscal deficit was paramount. It does appear to have the middle class in mind which will be the biggest beneficiary of these announcements. Funds have been channeled to areas which need attention as well as to areas where there would be growth multipliers (capex). More importantly, this has been done by ensuring that liquidity in the system is not affected which is a concern today given that the RBI regularly invokes enabling measures to ease the deficit.